A la Mode Pies West Seattle

Menu

• French Apple

  $42

  Locally grown Granny Smith apples baked with cinnamon atop a delicate shortbread crust, finished with a buttery, crumbly streusel topping — a comforting A la Mode classic with a little extra crunch. Serves 8

• Sour Cherry Pie

  $42

  Sour cherries with a touch of almond in a star-spangled crust. Serves 8

  ~1900 cal

• Seasonal Quiche

  $42

  The freshest seasonal vegetables and an assortment of cheeses baked inside a flaky puff pastry crust. Reheat at home. October 2026 Seasonal Variety Broccoli, Shallot & Cheddar Our new seasonal quiche combines fresh roasted broccoli, caramelized shallots and sharp cheddar delicately baked inside an a

• Crème Brûlée Cheesecake

  $60

  Go ahead, crack it! Tap through a crackly, golden layer of caramelized sugar to reach creamy, custardy vanilla bean cheesecake on a buttery graham cracker crust. It's two classic desserts in one, and that first crack never gets old. Serves 10.

  ~580 cal

• Mexican Chocolate Mousse

  $42

  Chocolate lovers, meet your new obsession. A crunchy chocolate graham-cracker crust cradles a cloud of silky chocolate mousse spiked with cinnamon and a sneaky hint of cayenne, all topped with fresh whipped cream. It's rich, airy, and warmly spiced, with a gentle kick that keeps you coming back for

• Holiday Pumpkin

  $47

  Our take on a classic, refined. A crisp, all-butter crust cradles a spiced pumpkin custard layered with cinnamon, clove, allspice, ginger, nutmeg, and vanilla, then finished with a delicate crème brulé crackle on top. Mounded with fresh whipped cream and crowned with cinnamon sugar crusted leaf cook

• Key Lime

  $42

  We don’t say “most perfect of all time” lightly. This key lime pie is bright, tangy and smooth, balancing sweet and tart, in a buttery graham cracker crust. It’s like a mini vacation, no sunscreen needed. Serves 8, so bring friends (or plan on leftovers). Serves 8

• Wild BEARy Pie

  $47

  Two grizzly critics helped inspire this one. Fresh raspberries and marionberries heap under a buttery oat-walnut crumble, all tucked into our signature all-butter crust (the good stuff, made the slow way). Sweet, tart, a little wild — exactly how a pie named after two beloved bears should behave. An

  ~1900 cal

• Cinnamon Toast Crunch

  $65

  Turning America’s favorite breakfast cereal into a dessert is a fantastic idea for adding a sweet, nostalgic crunch to a rich, velvety treat. Adding ground cinnamon directly to the batter really brings out that classic flavor.

• BOO-tterfinger Cheesecake

  $65

  This Halloween, a spooky-good treat is haunting our pie case. Our Boo-tterfinger Cheesecake starts with a buttery graham cracker crust, then fills it with a silky, velvety cheesecake studded with crunchy chunks of Butterfinger in every bite. Sweet, salty, creamy, and crunchy. It’s a treat with no tr

  ~580 cal

• Maple Pecan

  $47

  A generous layer of toasted pecans (a total of 4 cups) set in a rich, gooey filling with a touch of maple syrup, baked in our buttery all-butter crust — classic pecan pie the way it's meant to be, made from real, simple ingredients.

• Cookies & Scream!

  $47

  A Halloween treat that's frightfully good! Dark-chocolate custard and everyone's favorite sandwich cookie folded with whipped cream and placed in a chocolate graham crust, topped with more whipped cream, Oreo "dirt," and buried gummy worms. Serves 8.

  ~250 cal

• French Apple Petite

  $13

  Locally grown Granny Smith apples baked with cinnamon atop a delicate shortbread crust, finished with a buttery, crumbly streusel topping — a comforting A la Mode classic with a little extra crunch. Serves 2

• Sour Cherry Petite

  $13

  Cherries with a touch of almond in a patriotic crust of flaky stars. Serves 2.

• Key Lime Petite

  $13

  We don’t say “most perfect of all time” lightly. This key lime pie is bright, tangy and smooth, balancing sweet and tart, in a buttery graham cracker crust. It’s like a mini vacation, no sunscreen needed. Serves 8, so bring friends (or plan on leftovers). Serves 2.

• Cookies & Scream! Petite

  $15

  A Halloween treat that's frightfully good! Dark-chocolate custard and everyone's favorite sandwich cookie folded with whipped cream and placed in a chocolate graham crust, topped with more whipped cream, Oreo "dirt," and buried gummy worms. Serves 2.

  ~250 cal

• Petite Pie Sampler

  $45

  Indulge in a unique tasting experience and treat yourself to a selection of our best varieties in a petite size. Order four petite pies at a discount, select your preferred flavors, and prepare for a tasting experience like no other.

  ~1900 cal